Sunday, March 17, 2013

Shelley Hirsch - O Little Town of East New York (1995)

Shelley Hirsch is an American performer from New York. She's been involved in various areas of the arts - from theatre, to film, and, most importantly, music. She first began working in an experimental theatre troupe, but went on to study some more experimental and extended vocal techniques.  A lot of those ideas are explored on this extremely bizarre, interesting and unique album.

Much like Hubert Selby Junior's "Last Exit to Brooklyn", "O Little Town Of East New York" provides a really character-driven look into a side of New York that many might not see. But unlike Selby's dark, obscene magnum opus, "O Little Town Of East New York" is a beautiful, albeit odd description of a Jewish Neighborhood, and the many characters that inhabit it. What I really love about this album is how three-dimensional the characters are - Hirsch creates characters that seem so real and detailed, you can't help but imagine them fleshed out, strolling the streets of New York, or sitting inside, reading Dostoevsky -the whole album so lovely and picturesque. Now, this album is part of Tzadik's Radical Jewish Culture, and yes, Hirsch's proud sense of Jewish identity shines through on this - Skinheads might be disappointed, but to everyone else, it's a great addition to Tzadik's roster - the range of Jewish characters she conjures up are anything but stereotypical, and really add to the the three-dimensionality of the characters and the overall narrative of Hirsch's album.

And while I would classify this as Spoken Word, Hirsch's voice is not just flat, monotonous monologues - Hirsh's voice soars and bellows, going from playful sing-song to crazed yelling, and occasionally, beautiful singing. It's a very varied album in terms of vocal delivery, and Hirsch's experimentation only makes me love this absolutely bizarre album even more. On another not, the instrumentation on this album is extremely varied and bizarre as well, and I love it. It goes from odd and off-kilter bleeps and bloops to screeching violins, to plaintive piano ditties - it's absolutely lovely, and it perfectly complements the music.

Overall, this album is a lovely addition to Tzadik's Radical Jewish Culture - the characters seem so real and fleshed-out, Hirsch's unorthodox and oft-changing vocal delivery, coupled with the idiosyncratic and strange instrumentation makes this an extremely unique album that will completely captivate you.



  1. Thats sweet thank you so much for writing it.
    So glad you enjoyed it .
    Hope you don't mind but I feel the need to point out that i was trying to convey, evoke, something about a multicultural neighborhood most of whom were not Jewish, like the Russian Orthodox, Dostoevsky reading Finchenko family who I sing /speak about, and Marsha Calabro whose family was Italian American- she converted to Judaism in her 20's and Frank Torreto from the Crescent St. gang who was a church goer at the Church I used to sneak into, wishing i could go to confession. Originally I didn't want the cd to be on the Radical Jewish series because i thought it would put the focus be more on Jewishness than about a multicultural neighborhood in change.
    When I was 11 owe were one of 2 Jewish families on a mostly rascist Italian Irish Street-just blocks away from the projects....
    But I am nonetheless very appreciative of what you wrote and your writing!!
    And wow--nice to have Hubert Selbys great book in the same article.
    With kind regards

    1. I can't believe you found this tiny blog, I love your music, thanks for taking the time to read one of our reviews on it. :)

    2. Thanks so much for the kind words, I thought the album was just fantastic, one of the best "spoken word" (for lack of a better term) records I've heard thus far. I definitely understand about your sentiment about wanting to portray a multicultural community, I did get that aspect of it - I can see what you mean Tzadik's series influencing people, I did find the idea of Jewish Identity, seen from various sides, to be one of the most pivotal points of the album, but to me, the major draw of the album is just how fleshed-out and three dimensional all the characters feel, you really are a great storyteller. As Jarrod said, thanks so much for taking your time to read one of our reviews!

    3. AND...Another wonderful...original discovery...Thank You.....

    4. Wow, how cool is that? Shelley Hirsch herself comments on yr blog. Totally jealous. LoL.